WiFi waste of money?

NevChap replied on 27/04/2018 10:51

Posted on 27/04/2018 10:51

OK tin hat firmly in place. Here goes. I know that members have asked repeatedly about upgrading or installing WiFi on club sites and I read that large sums of our money are used to try to give decent coverage across as many sites as possible. However, are we not just throwing good money away with the pace of technology outstripping our efforts to catch up. When I go on a club site I no longer rely on the club WiFi but use my iPhone (other phones are available) to access the Internet and even piggy back a laptop or tablet, increasingly via 4g and soon to be 5g. This method is usually superior to the WiFi available on site. Now I know that at the moment not everyone has that facility but increasingly more and more people are.  In which case why keep trying to provide WiFi on a catch up basis costing a great deal of money. For what it's worth I would want to provide a decent WiFi signal close to reception that we could access maybe from a suitable 'shed' so that people could check emails and surf the 'net. This could be provided much more cheaply than a system which tries to cover the complete site: after all there has to be a decent connection for the site office to be able to run smoothly.

OK we may 'want' to sit in our caravan or motorhome and access the Internet but is it really cost effective for the club to spend huge sums providing this when better systems can be employed by individuals?

Just a thought, I'll now crawl into the bunker!

SteveL replied on 27/04/2018 10:58

Posted on 27/04/2018 10:58

The WiFi is supplied by an external contractor and is charged for by a fee paid directly to them. I don't know what the tie in is with the club as far as financials are concerned, but unless it is costing the club lots of money, over and above the WiFi access fees, is there really a problem. Those who don't want the service don't pay. I doubt the club is likely to provide any cost information, so we will almost certainly never know if they are spending huge sums of money as you suggest.

DavidKlyne replied on 27/04/2018 14:09

Posted on 27/04/2018 14:09

I wonder if we tend to forget that when the Club embarked on the supply of WiFi to sites that data plans via a phone or Mifi hardly existed. If we still only used our phones for voice calls that situation would still exist. However things have moved on and data use via our phones probably accounts for the majority of phone use these days. Perhaps, if the Club had waited a few years, they may not have installed Wifi in the first place? I am often critical of Club Wifi as I find that it can be slow with dropped connections regardless of whether the site is Gold, Silver or Bronze. I rarely get a speed of more than 1 MB usually half that. However it does work after a fashion. I suppose in many ways we are spoiled by our home connections which are often high speed. What I have found is that I increasing use my phone to check e-mails, look at online banking and get the latest News whereas in the past I would have done all that  on my laptop. The problem I have found in using my Windows laptop tethered to my phone using 4G is that it is very data intensive. However I did recently experiment with a small tablet and that used a lot less data which might be the way forward.

David

hastghyll replied on 27/04/2018 21:49

Posted on 27/04/2018 21:49

I think it depends on how important it is to be able to use the internet.

I tried the club Wi-Fi for a year but found coverage patchy. I've not bothered with it since.

I now just use my mobile, and have two phones on different networks to improve cover, however  on some sites you still cannot get a signal. For example last year I spent 6 weeks in Scotland where in a lot of locations you struggle to get a phone signal, never mind 4g. 

Not really a problem as when out and about you can generally catch up on emails and banking etc. On some sites just going up the road a bit makes a big difference. But if not then I don't worry. I'm not so addicted to social media that I have to keep looking at it.

brue replied on 28/04/2018 07:55

Posted on 27/04/2018 14:09 by DavidKlyne

I wonder if we tend to forget that when the Club embarked on the supply of WiFi to sites that data plans via a phone or Mifi hardly existed. If we still only used our phones for voice calls that situation would still exist. However things have moved on and data use via our phones probably accounts for the majority of phone use these days. Perhaps, if the Club had waited a few years, they may not have installed Wifi in the first place? I am often critical of Club Wifi as I find that it can be slow with dropped connections regardless of whether the site is Gold, Silver or Bronze. I rarely get a speed of more than 1 MB usually half that. However it does work after a fashion. I suppose in many ways we are spoiled by our home connections which are often high speed. What I have found is that I increasing use my phone to check e-mails, look at online banking and get the latest News whereas in the past I would have done all that  on my laptop. The problem I have found in using my Windows laptop tethered to my phone using 4G is that it is very data intensive. However I did recently experiment with a small tablet and that used a lot less data which might be the way forward.

David

Posted on 28/04/2018 07:55

Agree with this, technology has advanced except in areas of the country where it lags behind and we find we are definitely better off using our own supplier and can use more devices, the club only allows one connection. I've just said in another thread when travelling we tend to use our phones more now, earlier on we used the laptop. Even further back I used to leave my phone at home as I wanted to escape from 24 hour communications but like everyone else now I seem to have become willingly tethered!

paul56 replied on 28/04/2018 09:49

Posted on 28/04/2018 09:49

Interesting post. I'm retired and don't need to access emails etc particularly while we are away and have never used the Club wifi but I am using my phone (android) more and more to access the internet and find 4G (and less) adequate for my needs. 

I suppose in this day and age some people will want/expect high speed connection and if they are willing to pay for it so be it - so long as it doesn't become part of the overall charge for the pitch. 

replied on 28/04/2018 09:58

Posted on 28/04/2018 07:55 by brue

Agree with this, technology has advanced except in areas of the country where it lags behind and we find we are definitely better off using our own supplier and can use more devices, the club only allows one connection. I've just said in another thread when travelling we tend to use our phones more now, earlier on we used the laptop. Even further back I used to leave my phone at home as I wanted to escape from 24 hour communications but like everyone else now I seem to have become willingly tethered!

Posted on 28/04/2018 09:58

It depends on how much time I get a usable system from CC. In the past OH rarely wished to use wifi and we carried a single 12'" laptop. Probably had usable wifi on at least 80 nights and so £25 was good value. Probably 20 nights when no wifi on CC. 

With both of us having tablets we may rethink next year. 

NevChap replied on 28/04/2018 11:40

Posted on 28/04/2018 11:40

I'm surprised but pleased that so many of the posts have generally agreed with me in that in today's age using your own personal phone or other device to access internet etc is the way forward, rather rely on the club providing access at quite a considerable cost. To quote the club:

Here at the Club we know how important having a decent Wi-Fi signal is, so we’ve invested £500,000 into our network - with a further £500,000 assigned in 2018.

So £1m investment in supplying something that almost becomes obsolete as soon as it is installed. Maybe we could think of other uses for our £1m?

replied on 28/04/2018 18:20

Posted on 28/04/2018 18:20

I have no interest in a smart phone. I want a phone that slips easily into the bottom corner of my front trouser pocket.  For internet I want a decent size screen. Because my usage of mobile phone is small I use PAYG. For me this often makes the annual CC charge reasonable as l use it frequently.

replied on 28/04/2018 18:20

Posted on 28/04/2018 18:20

Double post

NevChap replied on 29/04/2018 12:05

Posted on 29/04/2018 12:05

My suggestion was to make WiFi available in a certain area of a club site rather than the costly £1m investment to push it around the whole site. Why should we subsidise your use of the Internet ET?

Near Malvern Hills Club Campsite by Andrew Cole

Book a late escape

There's still availability at many popular UK Club campsites - find your perfect pitch today for a last minute trip!

Book now
Woman sitting in camping chair by Wastwater in the Lake District with her two dogs and picnic blanket

Follow us on Facebook

Follow the Caravan and Motorhome Club via our official Facebook page for latest news, holiday ideas, events, activities and special offers.

Photo of Wast Water, Lake District by Sue Peace
Visit Facebook