Visited for a week in September. After being there at Easter, snow, rain, sun, blue skies, a great return....but traveled home on the day of storm Ali. Not for the feint hearted. Site is spotless as add the showers and toilet facilities. A credit to the wardens who tirelessly worked on through wind and storm. A great dog walk and well organised. Gave 5 for peace and quiet, occasionally interrupted by landing planes. Edinburgh has 100,000+ aircraft movements a year. Used Flightradar and could see and identify every plane in and out. Had to buy an aquaroll and wardens directed me to Go outdoors a mile or so away...written down complete with postcode from memory. They are a great bunch. We'd booked an evening river cruise from south queensferry, vist to the castle, Jamie Oliver's Italian and a return visit to Britannia at Leith. Could have stayed another week.