Cost of charging an EV

NutsyH replied on 14/09/2022 16:02

Posted on 14/09/2022 16:02

I'll just throw this in for a bit of fun.

Per the Sunday Times motoring correspondent last Sunday, it is now more expensive to charge an EV at a "fast" public charging point (if you can find one that's working) mile for mile than it is to use diesel. Speculating that if HMG wish to pursue this nonsense of 2030, they will have to come up with some sort of help for EV users.

Its OK for those with home chargers (providing you don't drive far from home), or those using overnight trickle chargers as fitted to lamp posts somewhere in the UK (probably London - haven't seen any around here).

Fact also quoted: 31 million ICE cars currently on the road, 510,000 ev's. VW group (incl Audi and Porsche) are spending big bucks on developing engines running on bio fuels - as per F1 from 2026. Audi are signing up to F1 with a comment that they see bio fuels as the way forward for the masses. I can't help thinking that Carrie Johnson has jumped in far too quickly with the EV idea, hopefully the new Government will see sense and extend the deadline to a more realistic target.

ChocolateTrees replied on 15/09/2022 11:06

Posted on 14/09/2022 16:02 by NutsyH

I'll just throw this in for a bit of fun.

Per the Sunday Times motoring correspondent last Sunday, it is now more expensive to charge an EV at a "fast" public charging point (if you can find one that's working) mile for mile than it is to use diesel. Speculating that if HMG wish to pursue this nonsense of 2030, they will have to come up with some sort of help for EV users.

Its OK for those with home chargers (providing you don't drive far from home), or those using overnight trickle chargers as fitted to lamp posts somewhere in the UK (probably London - haven't seen any around here).

Fact also quoted: 31 million ICE cars currently on the road, 510,000 ev's. VW group (incl Audi and Porsche) are spending big bucks on developing engines running on bio fuels - as per F1 from 2026. Audi are signing up to F1 with a comment that they see bio fuels as the way forward for the masses. I can't help thinking that Carrie Johnson has jumped in far too quickly with the EV idea, hopefully the new Government will see sense and extend the deadline to a more realistic target.

Posted on 15/09/2022 11:06

This story has been picked up by a number of outlets, and has very much been cherry picked for numbers. 

Just for some real data. 

My car does about 3 miles per kWh (its not super efficient). An Ionity charger is 69p / kWh, resulting in 23p per mile. at £1.79 a litre - thats 35mpg. Not bad for a 400hp AWD car. But realistically, I don't pay 69p. I have a free subscription with the car for that charger at 30p per mile - 80mpg equiv. 

However, I almost never charge out and about - its all at home. 30p per kWh is easy, but with a night time tariff, its 7.5p, 322mpg equivalent. 

Now - not everyone can charge at home - thats very true - but well over 2/3rds of households can. 

As for bio-fuel - thats already here - its very expensive as it competes with food for land to be grown on. For synthetic fuel, it uses electricity as a base ingredient. Developing engines is not much use without having the fuels available at scale. 

The energy crisis is real in so far as we are all experiencing it. But the answer is not to shy away from electricity, but to embrace it from renewable energy sources. 

 

EmilysDad replied on 15/09/2022 13:35

Posted on 15/09/2022 11:06 by ChocolateTrees

This story has been picked up by a number of outlets, and has very much been cherry picked for numbers. 

Just for some real data. 

My car does about 3 miles per kWh (its not super efficient). An Ionity charger is 69p / kWh, resulting in 23p per mile. at £1.79 a litre - thats 35mpg. Not bad for a 400hp AWD car. But realistically, I don't pay 69p. I have a free subscription with the car for that charger at 30p per mile - 80mpg equiv. 

However, I almost never charge out and about - its all at home. 30p per kWh is easy, but with a night time tariff, its 7.5p, 322mpg equivalent. 

Now - not everyone can charge at home - thats very true - but well over 2/3rds of households can. 

As for bio-fuel - thats already here - its very expensive as it competes with food for land to be grown on. For synthetic fuel, it uses electricity as a base ingredient. Developing engines is not much use without having the fuels available at scale. 

The energy crisis is real in so far as we are all experiencing it. But the answer is not to shy away from electricity, but to embrace it from renewable energy sources. 

 

Posted on 15/09/2022 13:35

 ... However, I almost never charge out and about - its all at home.

Apart from when you're towing 😉 and hoping up/down the country a bit at a time 

NutsyH replied on 16/09/2022 07:50

Posted on 16/09/2022 07:50

Now - not everyone can charge at home - thats very true - but well over 2/3rds of households can.

Maybe of the 510,000 current EV users they can. Very selective comment. When we are all forced into this crazy project, it is "estimated" that less than a 3rd of users will be able to charge at home. And where is all the electric coming from ? New Nuclear won't be here in my lifetime, but the greens seem hell bent on carpeting the land and sea with windmills. Its fine in the remote areas of  France etc - but in this overcrowded island, do we really want these eyesores?

In the same paper, houses for sale, there was a croft on an isolated Scottish island with around 50 acres, for circa £600,000. Tellingly, the advert stated that the croft also has 2 windmills, generating annual income of £150,000, but being sold seperately not as part of the house sale. This tells you where all our "green" taxes go. For £75k per annum, I'd have one in my garden.

If  HMG are really serious about the net zero project, they should start by putting appropriate infrastructure in place before forcing their vanity projects on the public. The only way they have even reached 510,000 EV's is by tax give aways and concessions, funded by the rest of us, many of whom cannot benefit from those concessions. 

 

Tinwheeler replied on 16/09/2022 08:12

Posted on 16/09/2022 08:12

For the record, Nutsy, I chose to buy an EV for various reasons because it suits me and my lifestyle. I didn't get it particularly for 'green' reasons and I received not a single penny from the Govt/tax payers either towards its purchase or the installation of the charger.

You seem to now be drifting well away from the cost of charging EVs and into a political discussion.

ChocolateTrees replied on 16/09/2022 12:37

Posted on 15/09/2022 13:35 by EmilysDad

 ... However, I almost never charge out and about - its all at home.

Apart from when you're towing 😉 and hoping up/down the country a bit at a time 

Posted on 16/09/2022 12:37

Sure - but given I do about 12K-15K miles a year and only 1000 to 1600 towing, its a small amount.

Others may have other levels of usage. 

ChocolateTrees replied on 16/09/2022 12:54

Posted on 16/09/2022 07:50 by NutsyH

Now - not everyone can charge at home - thats very true - but well over 2/3rds of households can.

Maybe of the 510,000 current EV users they can. Very selective comment. When we are all forced into this crazy project, it is "estimated" that less than a 3rd of users will be able to charge at home. And where is all the electric coming from ? New Nuclear won't be here in my lifetime, but the greens seem hell bent on carpeting the land and sea with windmills. Its fine in the remote areas of  France etc - but in this overcrowded island, do we really want these eyesores?

In the same paper, houses for sale, there was a croft on an isolated Scottish island with around 50 acres, for circa £600,000. Tellingly, the advert stated that the croft also has 2 windmills, generating annual income of £150,000, but being sold seperately not as part of the house sale. This tells you where all our "green" taxes go. For £75k per annum, I'd have one in my garden.

If  HMG are really serious about the net zero project, they should start by putting appropriate infrastructure in place before forcing their vanity projects on the public. The only way they have even reached 510,000 EV's is by tax give aways and concessions, funded by the rest of us, many of whom cannot benefit from those concessions. 

 

Posted on 16/09/2022 12:54

Nutsy, according to the DfT paper from Feb 2022, (page 8 section 2.1) just under a quarter (24%) of UK households don't have access to off road parking. Thats all households, not EV households. Government numbers, not mine. 

https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/1061865/public-ev-charging-infrastructure-research-report.pdf

Electricity is not an issue. The UK peak usage was in 2010, we have been using less and less as a country since then. Sure - if everyone tried to plug in and charge at peak busy hour (5pm to 8pm) we would push the generation infrastructure, but given there is a 10GW gap between peak and offpeak, we can use that excess generation. 

I would far rather have wind farms (on and off shore) over nuclear and gas. Especially as it will lower bills. I have bought into a windfarm. Just south of Ayr. When its up and generating (Nov '23) my share will generate enough electricty for my household for the year. 

Almost all the infrastructure for EVs is now privately funded and owned, just like traditional fuel stations. The government are seeding the market with cars to create a used pool that can be passed on as time goes by. Not everyone will want or buy a brand new EV. Many people never buy brand new cars. That's fine. The 2nd hand market for ICE vehicles will still be operating long after 2030. In the mean time, the price of EVs (compared to ICE) is slowly falling, and it wont be long until they are the same. People will vote with their wallets. 

 

 

NutsyH replied on 16/09/2022 15:39

Posted on 16/09/2022 08:12 by Tinwheeler

For the record, Nutsy, I chose to buy an EV for various reasons because it suits me and my lifestyle. I didn't get it particularly for 'green' reasons and I received not a single penny from the Govt/tax payers either towards its purchase or the installation of the charger.

You seem to now be drifting well away from the cost of charging EVs and into a political discussion.

Posted on 16/09/2022 15:39

Apart from not having to pay VED...........yet.

ChocolateTrees replied on 16/09/2022 16:46

Posted on 16/09/2022 15:39 by NutsyH

Apart from not having to pay VED...........yet.

Posted on 16/09/2022 16:46

I have a 1.0l Kia Picanto on the drive that my daughter is learing to drive in. That has  £0 VED too. And so was my previous Volvo V60 D6 2.5L PHEV. £0 VED is not constrained to EVs only. 

brue replied on 16/09/2022 18:29

Posted on 16/09/2022 18:29

Nutsy, Hinkley Point C comes on line in 2027, only five years to go...smile

No-one seems to worry that they haven't got a petrol pump by their front door, hopefully the bigger charging stations will return a feeling of security as EVs and the infrastrutcure improve.

You quoted VW Nutsy but most manufacturers are aiming for all electric, the list is long. smile

Tinwheeler replied on 16/09/2022 18:58

Posted on 16/09/2022 15:39 by NutsyH

Apart from not having to pay VED...........yet.

Posted on 16/09/2022 18:58

As ChocT said, it’s not just EV's and I think my diesel MH contributes handsomely with VED and fuel duty. I am also realistic enough to realise the Govt will find a way to tax EVs before too much longer. 

I'm happy to embrace the future. Try it and see.

Near Malvern Hills Club Campsite by Andrew Cole

Book a late escape

There's still availability at many popular UK Club campsites - find your perfect pitch today for a last minute trip!

Book now
Woman sitting in camping chair by Wastwater in the Lake District with her two dogs and picnic blanket

Follow us on Facebook

Follow the Caravan and Motorhome Club via our official Facebook page for latest news, holiday ideas, events, activities and special offers.

Photo of Wast Water, Lake District by Sue Peace
Visit Facebook