CLs instead of Club sites

GTrimmer replied on 10/10/2021 13:40

Posted on 10/10/2021 13:40

Have a look - there are many CLs which offer EHU, showers and WC significantly cheaper than a pitch on a club site. Rarely (at present) more than £20 a night, most are significantly less .

Yes, you don't get 'street lights' , but there are hard standings in many and some are increasingly offering 'Super' pitches, and no infernal pegs either tongue-out

Cartledge replied on 19/11/2021 18:32

Posted on 19/11/2021 18:32

I suppose many CLs are cheaper but still offer good facilities. CC is more expensive, but then CC income supports a web site, a discussion group on here, booking facilities for UK and overseas sites, tech advice, and all the admin that goes with a big organisation. The annual sub probably doesn’t cover that. 

obbernockle replied on 19/11/2021 18:47

Posted on 19/11/2021 18:05 by young thomas

"With the price of electricity rising year on year, and the recently announced major increases, many CL sites have now chosen to meter the use of EHU and charge visitors for EHU per kWh at cost price in line with the OFGEM regulations."

this is interesting in that we are regularly told that, despite many comments on CT where it was hoped the overall electric usage/bill could/should be lowered using metering, lower breaker values or a non-EHU option, the Club couldnt recoup any costs to carry out any of the above without price rises...

How can a 5 van site cover their costs for metering and maintain prices, and couldn't any plan they use be replicated to a larger site or group of sites ( et work)?

Posted on 19/11/2021 18:47

It appears to me that our club is managed by people with a very different mindset to the one  posted here by a CL owner.

Cornersteady replied on 19/11/2021 19:07

Posted on 19/11/2021 18:05 by young thomas

"With the price of electricity rising year on year, and the recently announced major increases, many CL sites have now chosen to meter the use of EHU and charge visitors for EHU per kWh at cost price in line with the OFGEM regulations."

this is interesting in that we are regularly told that, despite many comments on CT where it was hoped the overall electric usage/bill could/should be lowered using metering, lower breaker values or a non-EHU option, the Club couldnt recoup any costs to carry out any of the above without price rises...

How can a 5 van site cover their costs for metering and maintain prices, and couldn't any plan they use be replicated to a larger site or group of sites ( et work)?

Posted on 19/11/2021 19:07

Have prices been maintained after installation? Difficult to know perhaps? I assume CL's do out their prices up?

I think it  may be more about finding the money as well? The highest quote for a meter per bollard has been £500, which no one has disputed. Could be lower but there is a cost.

So a five site CL will cost £2500 or less, which I think is quite achievable for a business to raise that? A CL owner might think that makes it more attractive to potential CL users and people like yourself  with good gas and SP setup and makes the price look more attractive and so worth it to them to spend that money as well as being easier to manage?

For the club however that would be £5 million - more difficult to raise?

brue replied on 19/11/2021 19:14

Posted on 19/11/2021 11:55 by eurortraveller

That one, or it’s twin, is not far from me. The one where a review says the electric hook up is hidden in a clump of nettles?  So £16 a night to park there, or £20 at a proper non CL site not too far away where the owners have made an effort.  It really does take all sorts. 

Posted on 19/11/2021 19:14

For various reasons over the years and two owners( if we're talking about the same site) it hasn't had consistent care. However it has it's devotees who accept these things and appreciate the beauty of the setting and access to a tidal creek for boats and fishing etc. Not every CL needs to be manicured does it, for us, in this instance, it's location and access to nature.

young thomas replied on 19/11/2021 20:44

Posted on 19/11/2021 19:07 by Cornersteady

Have prices been maintained after installation? Difficult to know perhaps? I assume CL's do out their prices up?

I think it  may be more about finding the money as well? The highest quote for a meter per bollard has been £500, which no one has disputed. Could be lower but there is a cost.

So a five site CL will cost £2500 or less, which I think is quite achievable for a business to raise that? A CL owner might think that makes it more attractive to potential CL users and people like yourself  with good gas and SP setup and makes the price look more attractive and so worth it to them to spend that money as well as being easier to manage?

For the club however that would be £5 million - more difficult to raise?

Posted on 19/11/2021 20:44

Hopefully CG can provide more detail, hence my question to him. 

The point is, like the club, a CL won't be able to recoup that investment by increasing electric charges so it's dead money..why invest it if not to stop pitch prices running away and ensuing loss of business.

yes, the absolute numbers are higher for the club but the ratio per night visit is the same.

eventually those passed on electric prices will be taken notice of even by the most stalwart of CC customers. 

 

Cornersteady replied on 19/11/2021 21:29

Posted on 19/11/2021 20:44 by young thomas

Hopefully CG can provide more detail, hence my question to him. 

The point is, like the club, a CL won't be able to recoup that investment by increasing electric charges so it's dead money..why invest it if not to stop pitch prices running away and ensuing loss of business.

yes, the absolute numbers are higher for the club but the ratio per night visit is the same.

eventually those passed on electric prices will be taken notice of even by the most stalwart of CC customers. 

 

Posted on 19/11/2021 21:29

oThe point is, like the club, a CL won't be able to recoup that investment by increasing electric charges so it's dead money..why invest it if not to stop pitch prices running away and ensuing loss of business

Well as I said I think (might be wrong) that the £2500 needed or much less would be quite easy to raise for a business? A simple loan could cover it? Again I'm not nor ever have been in business so don't quote me on that but I personally don't think £2500 for a business or even an individual is a lot (yes I know lucky me I sure people will say)

The point I was trying to make that while it may be lost money a CL owner might think it might bring in more business by either appearing to offer a lower price and/or be more attractive to people with outfits like your self who say they want or like the idea of non paying for EHU and don't want full fat club sites all the time. Does anyone think that the club bringing in metering will lead to an increase in booking's? I don't but just my view and anyway would that matter, the club is getting more bookings that it can supply at times?

yes, the absolute numbers are higher for the club but the ratio per night visit is the same

Irrelevant in my view as it is the amount that needs to be found that is the important factor (and can it be 'written off' if it doesn't pay off? £2500 might be?) and as I said the club will need to find £5,000,000.

Has the growing prices put anyone off yet? Are they likely to? I'm not sure at all. people will see their own energy costs rise and just accept the club has to too? Like you I've been on this forum a long time, and every year the prices are complained about yet club usage continues to rise.

In fact how many questions at the AGM were about high prices? Not one I recall, yet quite a  number of not getting a pitch. 

But and the end of the day the club has decided not to go down this route at this time and perhaps for a few years.

Tinwheeler replied on 19/11/2021 21:38

Posted on 19/11/2021 21:38

Btw, let’s not forget that expenditure on upgrading a site will be tax deductible and VAT paid on achieving it will be reclaimable which may be especially useful to a small business such as a CL.

Wherenext replied on 19/11/2021 22:42

Posted on 19/11/2021 22:42

In the last 10 years I have stayed on well over 100 CLs at a very conservative estimate. I have yet to stay on one that has metred electricity. In fact I have never stayed on a CL which has metres, AFAIR.

I am therefore puzzled as to how CG can state "many" when talking about CL owners installing them. There may well be a few more than there used to be but, many? I think not. Let's not overhype the situation.

I have seen CLs increase their prices in winter months on a more frequent basis and I can see CL prices in general increasing judging by my recently arranged new home energy tariff which had a significant hike. 

But, lots of meters there ain't.

cyberyacht replied on 20/11/2021 08:31

Posted on 20/11/2021 08:31

Corners wrote "Has the growing prices put anyone off yet?"

Yes, me for one. I haven't used a single CAMC site this year. I have, however, used 7 C&CC ones, 1 commercial, 1 THS, 7 CLs or associated Venue facilities plus 4 "freebie" nights.

The above has enabled me to keep my pitch cost average to £13.12 over the course of the year.

As for sociability, part of our reason for touring is for peace and quiet so social interaction isn't high on our list but it doesn't stretch to avoiding eye contact. 

young thomas replied on 20/11/2021 08:56

Posted on 20/11/2021 08:31 by cyberyacht

Corners wrote "Has the growing prices put anyone off yet?"

Yes, me for one. I haven't used a single CAMC site this year. I have, however, used 7 C&CC ones, 1 commercial, 1 THS, 7 CLs or associated Venue facilities plus 4 "freebie" nights.

The above has enabled me to keep my pitch cost average to £13.12 over the course of the year.

As for sociability, part of our reason for touring is for peace and quiet so social interaction isn't high on our list but it doesn't stretch to avoiding eye contact. 

Posted on 20/11/2021 08:56

Our touring here this year has seen a similar mix of site providers...CC, when used, won't be at the cheaper end...so, yes, cost is an influence.

I might be a 'lucky me' too, in that I can afford to stay on sites where I choose, but I don't like to be on the end of ever increasing cost where I don't feel I'm getting any more for it when compared to the competition.

location will usually drive our site selection but, where choices are similar, cost will probably come next....so, a nice CL or CCC site as 'handy' as the nearest CC one would probably get our vote.

no doubt the club's view will be to maintain its current pricing policy....the customer picks up the ever increasing tab. 

Near Malvern Hills Club Campsite by Andrew Cole

Book a late escape

There's still availability at many popular UK Club campsites - find your perfect pitch today for a last minute trip!

Book now
Woman sitting in camping chair by Wastwater in the Lake District with her two dogs and picnic blanket

Follow us on Facebook

Follow the Caravan and Motorhome Club via our official Facebook page for latest news, holiday ideas, events, activities and special offers.

Photo of Wast Water, Lake District by Sue Peace
Visit Facebook