Weights and payloads

eribaMotters replied on 21/01/2021 11:18

Posted on 21/01/2021 11:18

I must admit this is a sore point for me and I admit I'm  narrow minded, but it really is a safety issue that I believe manufacturers should address.

I contacted the club following a magazine review of a very nice twin axle a couple of months ago. It made many berths, was big and heavy with lots of storage, but a very poor payload. 

When on sites UK and abroad, CL's, independent and club I am amazed and saddened at the stuff owners drag out of there vans. Just because they have the space they think they can fill it, but vans turn up and it is obvious they are overloaded. 

I have not gone as far as to weighbridge my van, as I know some have, but I keep a list of accurate weights in an attempt to keep on top of things and with correct loading remain safe.

So what do your vans actually weigh ready for you to fill and what are your real payloads?

I'll start with mine:-

2017 Eriba 430 - 3 berth

basic weight = 840kg - 30kg for BS EN 1646-2 gas/water allowance = 810kg

Add factory fit extras and mover at 125kg = 935kg

Max permissible load of 1200kg = 265kg [now available with 1300kg axle for 365kg] payload

 

Colin

young thomas replied on 25/06/2021 16:00

Posted on 25/06/2021 16:00

2017 Carthago C-compactline i138 - 4 berth.

originally plated at 3850Kg but i wanted to run it at 3500kg, if possible.

After fully loading for European trip I drove to the local weighbridge still with 120 ltr of water and 90 litres of fuel along with all bedding, pots, pans, tools, food, wine and ebikes and the two adults at about 115 kg.

Whole Gross: 3420 Kg.

Front axle: 1600 Kg.

Rear axle: 1820 Kg.

I, too, sent these figures off to Michelin and they kindly sent me back a set of tyre pressures for various weight loads.

so, fully loaded with as much as I would ever carry, 80 Kg spare (for more wine on the return) and loads of axle weight spare.

 

cyberyacht replied on 26/06/2021 07:24

Posted on 26/06/2021 07:24

I'm obviously carrying too many cans of baked beans. Mine came in at 3460Kg and I haven't got the dropdown bed in mine. Do you carry a spare wheel? One wonders what the tolerances are on weigh bridges. As they are designed to weigh substantially heavier loads than our relatively puny motorhomes, are they sensitive enough to pick up the odd 20-30Kg?

young thomas replied on 26/06/2021 14:30

Posted on 26/06/2021 14:30

CY, i carry a spare tyre only, no wheel....

when i was looking to buy this van, i checked out a very low mileage one at Southdowns, similar extras but auto box...

i had it weighed and there was quite a difference between that one and the weight in known condition or the in i bought, which i also had weighed.

this is why a buyer cant rely on brochures.....or salesmen.

once i knew the actual weight of the van and what was going to be added to it, i coyld calculate accurately my final MIRO, and thus payload.

when i actuslly weighed it all up against my 'calculated prediction' i was only 20kg out.

Roger McNair replied on 26/06/2021 15:01

Posted on 21/01/2021 11:18 by eribaMotters

I must admit this is a sore point for me and I admit I'm  narrow minded, but it really is a safety issue that I believe manufacturers should address.

I contacted the club following a magazine review of a very nice twin axle a couple of months ago. It made many berths, was big and heavy with lots of storage, but a very poor payload. 

When on sites UK and abroad, CL's, independent and club I am amazed and saddened at the stuff owners drag out of there vans. Just because they have the space they think they can fill it, but vans turn up and it is obvious they are overloaded. 

I have not gone as far as to weighbridge my van, as I know some have, but I keep a list of accurate weights in an attempt to keep on top of things and with correct loading remain safe.

So what do your vans actually weigh ready for you to fill and what are your real payloads?

I'll start with mine:-

2017 Eriba 430 - 3 berth

basic weight = 840kg - 30kg for BS EN 1646-2 gas/water allowance = 810kg

Add factory fit extras and mover at 125kg = 935kg

Max permissible load of 1200kg = 265kg [now available with 1300kg axle for 365kg] payload

 

Colin

Posted on 26/06/2021 15:01

Colin - you are right to be concerned. Payload was the biggest issue for us when looking to buy a motorhome then a caravan. When I picked up out new Coachman Laser 575 I took it to a local weigh bridge (weight tolerance +/- 20kgs and was pleasantly surprised to find it came in very close to Coachman's predicted unladen weight making allowances for A/c, leisure battery and motormovers etc. Everything which has subsequently been put into the caravan has been weighed. 

The industry faces huge challenges over weight in terms of increasing payload and decreasing MTPLMs to enable PHEVs and electric cars a chance of towing.   

EmilysDad replied on 29/06/2021 19:29

Posted on 29/06/2021 19:25 by HarryTheHymer

< MTPLM 1350kg, payload 300kg, I can up plate it to 500kg.

I doubt even my wife could defeat that!

Posted on 29/06/2021 19:29

 ... I doubt even my wife could defeat that!

Is that a challenge? 😉😉

young thomas replied on 30/06/2021 07:34

Posted on 30/06/2021 07:34

i certainly know of one mh purchaser who, on paper, appeared to have around 500kg payload (a heavy, long van on a Fiat 4250kg chassis) and he ticked so many options and accessories that the van was actually unusable (even when upgraded to 4500kg) and it went back to the dealer and the identical vehicle was 'negotiated' but this time built on an Iveco (upto 6.7t) base.

you can obviously never have too much payload😢

JVB66 replied on 30/06/2021 08:09

Posted on 26/06/2021 15:01 by Roger McNair

Colin - you are right to be concerned. Payload was the biggest issue for us when looking to buy a motorhome then a caravan. When I picked up out new Coachman Laser 575 I took it to a local weigh bridge (weight tolerance +/- 20kgs and was pleasantly surprised to find it came in very close to Coachman's predicted unladen weight making allowances for A/c, leisure battery and motormovers etc. Everything which has subsequently been put into the caravan has been weighed. 

The industry faces huge challenges over weight in terms of increasing payload and decreasing MTPLMs to enable PHEVs and electric cars a chance of towing.   

Posted on 30/06/2021 08:09

That is one of the big problems as you say facing manufacturers worldwide, it has been seen in UK vans for years ,where buyers want all the latest bells and whistles in a four berth and or fixed bed ,and tow it it with a a small family saloon

Lutz replied on 30/06/2021 09:06

Posted on 30/06/2021 08:09 by JVB66

That is one of the big problems as you say facing manufacturers worldwide, it has been seen in UK vans for years ,where buyers want all the latest bells and whistles in a four berth and or fixed bed ,and tow it it with a a small family saloon

Posted on 30/06/2021 09:06

But that's more of an issue concerning the MTPLM and not payload. Even a caravan with a relatively big MTPLM are known to suffer from an inadequate payload margin. If the buyer wants a caravan with all bells and whistles it should be obvious that one needs to look out for a suitable payload margin which may drive the necessary MTPLM up to a level where a bigger towcar would be required.

KeithandMargaret replied on 31/07/2021 09:21

Posted on 31/07/2021 09:21

If you don't know the weight of the Caravan (when full up in holiday mode) how do you determine the tyre pressures for the weight they are carrying ?

Or isn't a Caravans weight as critical as a Motorhomes weight on each axle ?

Near Malvern Hills Club Campsite by Andrew Cole

Book a late escape

There's still availability at many popular UK Club campsites - find your perfect pitch today for a last minute trip!

Book now
Woman sitting in camping chair by Wastwater in the Lake District with her two dogs and picnic blanket

Follow us on Facebook

Follow the Caravan and Motorhome Club via our official Facebook page for latest news, holiday ideas, events, activities and special offers.

Photo of Wast Water, Lake District by Sue Peace
Visit Facebook